Fire and Ice
-Robert Frost
Some say the world will end in fire
Some say in ice.
From what I’ve tasted of desire
I hold with those who favour fire.
But if it had to perish twice,
I think I know enough of hate
To say that for destruction ice
Is also great
And would suffice.
Explanation
The poem "Fire and Ice" by Robert Frost presents a contrast between the fire of desire and the coldness of hate, both of which are powerful passions. The speaker reflects on the idea that the world may end either in fire or in ice, and expresses their preference for fire due to their experience with desire. However, they acknowledge that the coldness of hate is equally destructive, as it can lead to the same result of destruction and the end of the world. The poem implies that intense passion, whether it be the fiery desire or the icy hate, is capable of bringing about the end of the world. The contrast between the two emotions highlights the idea that both are equally dangerous and destructive, and serves as a warning against the dangers of unchecked passion.
Thinking About the Poem
Question 1. There are many ideas about how the world will ‘end’. Do you think the world will end some day? Have you ever thought what would happen if the sun got so hot that it ‘burst’, or grew colder and colder?
Answer:
It is widely accepted by scientists that the sun will eventually run out of fuel and expand into a red giant, engulfing the inner planets, before finally cooling down into a white dwarf. This process will likely take billions of years to occur.
As for the end of the world, there is currently no scientific evidence to support the idea that the world will end in a specific event. It's possible that events such as natural disasters, climate change, or even human actions could have significant impacts on life on Earth, but the Earth and the universe are expected to continue existing for a long time into the future.
Question 2. For Frost, what do ‘fire’ and ‘ice’ stand for?
Answer:
In Robert Frost's poem "Fire and Ice," "fire" and "ice" are used as metaphors to represent two opposing forces or passions. Fire is often associated with intense emotions, such as desire, passion, and energy. It is seen as a powerful and transformative force that can bring about change, but also destruction.
On the other hand, ice is often associated with coldness, detachment, and lack of emotion. It is seen as a force of destruction through its ability to freeze and preserve, but also to shatter and break.
In the poem, fire and ice are used to represent the two potential causes of the end of the world. The speaker suggests that the world may end due to the intense passion of fire or the intense hatred of ice, and reflects on the destructive power of both emotions. The contrast between the two forces serves as a reminder of the dangers of unchecked passion and the need for balance and moderation.
Question 3. What is the rhyme scheme of the poem? How does it help in bringing out the contrasting ideas in the poem?
Answer:
The rhyme scheme of Robert Frost's poem "Fire and Ice" 'is abaabcbcb'. This rhyme scheme, with its simple and repetitive pattern, helps to reinforce the contrast between the two opposing forces of fire and ice. The repetition of the rhyme reinforces the idea that the two forces are equal in their destructive power, and highlights the stark contrast between them.
The rhyme scheme also contributes to the overall rhythm and flow of the poem, making it easier to read and remember. The simple, straightforward language and repetition of the rhyme scheme add to the impact of the contrasting ideas, making them more memorable and emphasizing the importance of the message being conveyed.
In this way, the rhyme scheme supports the overall message of the poem, which is to highlight the dangers of unchecked passion and the need for balance and moderation. By using a simple rhyme scheme, Frost emphasizes the simplicity of the ideas being presented, making it easier for the reader to understand and internalize the message.
Extra Questions from old CBSE Examination Papers
Question 1. “Fire and Ice” was first published in 1920. Briefly explain how the WW I might have influenced the theme of the poem.
[CBSE QB, 2020-21]
"Fire and Ice" was first published in 1920, which was shortly after the conclusion of World War I in 1918. The War had a profound impact on the world and on the collective consciousness of the time, and it is likely that the events of the War influenced the theme of the poem in several ways.
First, the War was characterized by its destructive power and the widespread loss of life, and the poem's theme of the end of the world can be seen as an allegory for the devastating effects of the War. The contrast between fire and ice in the poem can also be seen as a representation of the opposing forces of good and evil that were at play during the War, with fire representing the passions and emotions that led to conflict, and ice representing the coldness and cruelty that characterized the War.
Additionally, the War marked a time of great change and upheaval in the world, with the collapse of old empires and the birth of new nations. The idea of the end of the world in the poem can also be seen as a representation of the end of an era and the birth of a new world order.
Question 2. According to the poet, what do ‘ice’ and ‘fire’ symbolise?
[CBSE QB, 2020-21]
Answer:
In Robert Frost's poem "Fire and Ice," "fire" and "ice" symbolize opposing forces or passions. Fire represents intense emotions such as desire and passion, while ice symbolizes coldness, detachment, and lack of emotion. The poem uses these symbols to represent the potential causes of the end of the world and highlights the destructive power of unchecked passion. The contrast between fire and ice serves as a reminder of the dangers of unchecked passion and the need for balance and moderation.
Question 3. What is the message of the poem ‘Fire and Ice’?
[CBSE QB, 2020-21]
Answer:
The message of Robert Frost's poem "Fire and Ice" is that unchecked passion, whether it be desire or hate, can lead to destruction. The poem presents two opposing forces, "fire" and "ice," which are used to represent the two potential causes of the end of the world. The speaker reflects on the destructive power of both emotions, suggesting that the world may end due to the intense passion of fire or the intense hatred of ice.
Question 4. The tone of the speaker contrasts with the seriousness of the subject matter. Justify.
[CBSE QB, 2020-21]
Answer:
The speaker of Robert Frost's poem "Fire and Ice" uses a light-hearted tone that contrasts with the serious subject matter of the poem. The speaker presents the idea of the end of the world with a sense of humor, as though it were a matter of personal preference, whether the world will end in fire or ice. The speaker's tone is nonchalant, almost whimsical, as they consider the two opposing forces and the consequences of each.
However, despite the light-hearted tone of the speaker, the subject matter of the poem is extremely serious. The end of the world is a weighty and somber topic, one that has been the subject of speculation and contemplation for centuries. The contrast between the speaker's light-hearted tone and the serious subject matter highlights the paradox of life and the human condition, reminding us of the importance of balancing humor and levity with seriousness and contemplation.
Question 5. Evaluate the line- Some say the world will end in fire/Some say in ice- in the context of volcanic eruptions, forest fires, meteor collisions, melting ice caps etc.
[CBSE QB, 2020-21]
Answer:
The line "Some say the world will end in fire/Some say in ice" from Robert Frost's poem "Fire and Ice" can be evaluated in the context of various natural disasters and environmental events, such as volcanic eruptions, forest fires, meteor collisions, and melting ice caps. This line highlights the idea that there are many different opinions and interpretations of the potential causes of the end of the world.
Volcanic eruptions and forest fires can be seen as representing the "fire" mentioned in the line, as they are destructive events that can cause widespread damage and loss of life. Similarly, meteor collisions and melting ice caps can be seen as representing the "ice" mentioned in the line, as they too have the potential to bring about the end of the world through their destructive power.
The line thus highlights the idea that there are many different forces and events that have the potential to bring about the end of the world. It serves as a reminder of the fragility of our planet and the importance of taking care of the environment to prevent potential disasters.
Question 6. Fire and Ice projects a pessimistic outlook. Comment.
[CBSE QB, 2020-21]
Answer:
Yes, "Fire and Ice" by Robert Frost projects a pessimistic outlook, as it suggests that the world may end due to the unchecked passions of desire or hate. The poem presents two opposing forces, "fire" and "ice," both of which have the potential to bring about the end of the world through their destructive power.
The poem reflects the idea that unchecked passion, whether it be the heat of desire or the coldness of hate, can lead to destruction. The speaker of the poem does not offer any hope for the future, but instead warns of the dangers of unchecked passion and the need for balance and caution in our emotions and actions.
In this way, "Fire and Ice" presents a bleak and pessimistic outlook on the future, highlighting the dangers of unchecked passion and the need for balance and control in our lives. The poem serves as a warning against the dangers of extremism and a reminder of the importance of moderation in all things.
Question 7. The use of symbolism in the poem ‘Fire and Ice’ conveys the poet’s message effectively. Expand with reference to the poem.
[CBSE QB, 2020-21]
Answer:
The use of symbolism in Robert Frost's poem "Fire and Ice" is a key element in conveying the poet's message effectively. The two opposing forces of "fire" and "ice" are used to symbolize two different forms of unchecked passion: desire and hate.
The "fire" symbolizes desire and its destructive power when left unchecked. The speaker of the poem suggests that the world may end due to the unchecked desire for pleasure and satisfaction, represented by the fire.
On the other hand, the "ice" symbolizes hate and its destructive power when left unchecked. The speaker suggests that the world may also end due to the unchecked hatred and coldness that can lead to conflict and destruction, represented by the ice.
The contrasting symbols of "fire" and "ice" effectively convey the poet's message of the dangers of unchecked passion and the need for balance and control in our lives. The poem highlights the idea that both desire and hate have the potential to bring about the end of the world through their destructive power.
Question 8. Most of your classmates, like Frost, feel that man’s greed and rage or hate, would lead the world to its destruction. You feel that the ‘fire and ice’ in Mankind can be addressed to create a harmonious world. Write a speech, for your classmates, expressing your belief/s with respect to the poem.
[CBSE QB, 2020-21]
Answer:
Ladies and Gentlemen,
Today, I would like to express my belief with respect to the poem "Fire and Ice" by Robert Frost. This poem is a classic representation of the dangers of unchecked passion and the need for balance and control in our lives.
The poem presents two opposing forces, "fire" and "ice," both of which have the potential to bring about the end of the world through their destructive power. The "fire" symbolizes desire, while the "ice" symbolizes hate. The speaker of the poem suggests that the world may end due to the unchecked desire for pleasure and satisfaction, or the unchecked hatred and coldness that can lead to conflict and destruction.
In my belief, this poem serves as a warning against the dangers of extremism and a reminder of the importance of moderation in all things. It highlights the idea that both desire and hate have the potential to bring about the end of the world through their destructive power, and emphasizes the need for balance and control in our lives.
Unchecked passion can lead to destruction and bring chaos to our world. Whether it is the heat of desire or the coldness of hate, both have the power to cause harm and bring about the end of the world. We need to be mindful of the passions that drive us and keep them in check, ensuring that they do not become destructive forces in our lives.
In conclusion, "Fire and Ice" is a powerful and thought-provoking poem that highlights the dangers of unchecked passion and the need for balance and control in our lives. I hope that its message will inspire us all to be mindful of our passions and to strive for balance and control in all aspects of our lives.
Thank you.
Question 9. How can Frost’s poem ‘Fire and Ice’ be read as an extended metaphor?
Answer:
"Fire and Ice" by Robert Frost can be read as an extended metaphor, where the two opposing forces of fire and ice symbolize different aspects of human behavior. The fire symbolizes desire, passion, and the heat of emotions, while the ice symbolizes hate, indifference, and coldness of emotions. The poem presents these two forces as two opposite sides of the same coin, and suggests that both have the potential to bring about the end of the world.
In the extended metaphor, the poem is not only about the end of the world, but also about the consequences of uncontrolled passions and emotions in human life. The poem presents a warning against the dangers of extremism and a reminder of the importance of moderation in all things. The poem suggests that both desire and hate have the power to bring about the end of the world, and that we need to be mindful of the passions that drive us and keep them in check, ensuring that they do not become destructive forces in our lives.
The use of the extended metaphor in the poem effectively conveys the poet's message about the dangers of unchecked passion and the need for balance and control in our lives. The contrasting images of fire and ice create a vivid and memorable visual that stays with the reader, making the message of the poem even more powerful and impactful.
In conclusion, "Fire and Ice" can be read as an extended metaphor that highlights the dangers of uncontrolled passion and the need for balance and control in human life.
